The 1935 Helena, Montana Earthquakes
--what happened and personal accounts retold
written 60 years later (1995), by Alison James, Helena High School sophomore, as part of a
research project for the Canyon Ferry Limnological Institute of Helena, Montana.
PREFACE
By Gil Alexander
The Helena earthquake of 1935 destroyed property and disrupted lives. It was not as devastating
as subsequent quakes in California or many other places on Earth, but it demonstrated how
susceptible we all are when we are at the mercy of natural forces.
Sixty years have passed (4 months from now) since the quake shook bricks and mortar from the
walls of Helena High. People who were students at Helena High and who still live in Helena get
together on a regular basis to have dinners and recount stories of the past. Their stories are a
legacy of Helena's history. Stories from the "High School on Wheels," rebuilding houses, and the
long winter of '35 all have their place in the memories of these Helena residents.
Somehow, these stories seemed far removed from my students in 1993 when this project began.
Students seem to always believe that history begins with their birth. Events of the past seldom
seem real to them. Our Geoscience class was beginning to study earthquakes and it seemed like a
perfect opportunity to drag the past into the present. I invited folks who still remembered the
earthquake to Helena High to be interviewed by my students. Approximately thirty people told
their stories and shared their knowledge of the '35 quake with my students. I asked students to
record those stories on audio tape and on paper. What resulted was a glimpse into people's lives.
The academic year came to an end and I hadn't had the time to collate the materials into a usable
format, so there the information sat in its folder. A whole year passed and still no time existed for
me to get the job done. Enter Alison. Alison James had been a student in the 9th grade
Geoscience class that had conducted the interviews and she was looking for an opportunity to
combine her journalism aspirations with a science project.
__________
The first shudder in the ground below Helena occurred on October 3rd, 1935. This was a mild
and almost unnoticeable quake which promoted nothing more than some curiosity and "barbershop
talk". Another quake occurred on October 12th, at 12:51 a.m. This one was somewhat more
intense, but caused no more damage than some cracked plaster and broken dishes.
During the next week, fifty-seven more tremors occurred. These tremors were thought to be
aftershocks of the quake on the twelfth, and they too were ignored. "Another Bad Earth Shock
Extremely Unlikely, Say Leading State Geologists," read the headlines of the Helena Independent
on October 16th, 1935.
Fred Buck, who lived in Helena with his family, was working at the State Water Conservation
Board during this time. In his personal account, written in December of 1935, Fred Buck said of
the tremors:
The six days that intervened between the 12th and the 18th were trying on the nerves to say the least.
Shocks kept following shocks, some severe and others mild, but none of very long duration.
However, on October 18th, 1935, the history of Helena was changed forever. It was an
ordinary Friday evening. The double feature that night at the Marlow Theater, on Main, was "It's
In the Air," starring Jack Benny and "Fighting Youth," starring Charles Farrell. A few blocks
away, the Rio Theater featured "The Case of the Lucky Legs," starring Warren William and
Patricia Ellis. High school students were preparing for Saturday's football against Butte with a
"snake dance" up and down main street. Other residents visited with friends, read, or played
cards. And some were just touching sleep in the warm peace of the evening dark.
The first taste of a tremor occurred at 8:04 p.m., when another quake, a little stronger than
usual, was felt. An hour later, at 9:47 p.m. the earth that Helena and her citizens rested on
suddenly began to shake. Violently, uncontrollably, Helena rocked with the shuddering earth.
This shock was no longer a minor tremor that could be easily overlooked. The ground rolled like
waves, bricks and mortar fell, buildings swayed, roofs fell in, walls collapsed.
Fred Buck was at his office on the second floor of the Montana Block, on the corner of Fuller
and Placer Avenues when the quake hit. He described the quake in his personal account:
The noise alone of grinding brick and groaning timbers, the rattling windows, and roar of the quake
itself, were enough to terrify one to say to nothing of being jostled about like a lone marble in a tomato
can. About that time the plaster came showering from the walls and ceiling, and in the midst of it all the
lights went out. There we were trying to stay on our feet while being swatted with falling plaster in the
ghastly darkness. It was an experience I never want to go through again. Every second I expected to be
shot out of the window to the pavement below, or have the walls crash around me. This terrible shaking
went kept up severely and constantly for a period of 32 seconds--it seemed like 32 minutes.....Old Mother
Earth reminded me of a dog full of fleas shaking himself to get rid of the dirt.
The land buckled and shook tremendously. Half a minute later, buildings in Helena were
reduced to rubble, dust and debris settling into a hazy suspension. The lights were out, the earth
was quiet, and a few moments of silent shock permeated the city.
Soon, the streets were crowded with panicked residents. People screamed, yelled and stared,
through the dust, at their trembling city. "Sis" Warren Southwick, a freshman in high school at the
time, described being in the Marlow theater:
So my cousin and I went to the Marlow Theater to see a Jack Benny movie. We liked to sit way up high
in the theater so we could look down on the movie. At 9:30 the seat seemed to be moving, a low rumble
was quite obvious even as the movie was so interesting. It got worse and worse and the air seemed to be
filled with smoke or dust. Looking down we could see the large chandelier swinging in a big arc, and the
chains that held it were rattling. Then the lights went out. Panic hit and people were screaming, trying to
get down to the ramp. We got to the ramp and it seemed to be swaying from side to side. People were
pushing , falling down and panic was at its utmost. One lady fell and was screaming for someone to help
her. It seemed the shaking would never stop and dust was so thick we could taste it. Everyone was
pushing to the bottom floor where the doors were. It was so dark outside all lights were out in downtown
Helena. As my Cousin and I finally got out we realized a man was holding us each by the hand. We did
not know him, but we were mighty thankful that we were finally out of the building.
Terrified people flooded into the dark streets. Electricity was out. An operator at the Montana
Power Company had realized what was happening, and cut off the city's electricity. This was a
major factor in preventing fires which could have ravaged the town.
The people of Helena watched and waited, unsure of what to do next. Superintendent of
Schools, C.R. Anderson, wrote in Montana Earthquakes (p.11):
Everywhere was great excitement. Up and down the streets could be seen little groups of excited
people. Children, in most cases, hovered close to these groups or clung tightly to parents. Cars were run
out of garages and their flashing beams of light added to the almost unreal aspect of the night. Neighbor
shouted to neighbor, experiences were exchanged, prognostications made. It was that period which comes
after a great strain. Over all was an atmosphere of expectancy--of waiting--waiting for something more to
happen, and trying to realize what had already happened. In their keyed up conditions these victims of a
moving knew that anything could happen.
The lights were still out, but hundreds of headlights and flashlights punctured that darkness. Tremors
were coming almost constantly, a movement barely felt, but breaking out every few minutes into stronger,
sharper quaking.
Some victims, too frightened to stay the night, packed their belongings and their families into
cars and left. In his memoirs, Perry Brackett, who was a boy at the time of the quake, wrote:
I remember my Dad saying it was as though someone had kicked into an ant hill. Cars were going
anywhere and everywhere. Some of them just wanted to get out of town.
Those who stayed held vigil throughout the night. Mattresses were placed in truck beds and on
lawns for children to sleep in. People lit campfires in vacant lots to keep warm, and garages
provided a place to lay blankets and cots. Others, whose houses were still stable, simply went
back to bed.
The shuddering city slept, though likely it was a difficult and uneasy rest. Many were too
disturbed to sleep, and for them it was a long, anxious wait for dawn.
*****
Morning rose over a trembling, yet calm Helena. Daylight showed the city to be humbled,
wounded, but alive still. C.R. Anderson wrote in Montana Earthquakes (p. 14):
At long last the dawn came.....The sun was just poking over the mountains and throwing its fingers across
the city to towering Mount Helena, on whose slopes we were situated. In the distance, over the city and the
valley towered the rugged peaks of the Rockies, some standing out boldly, while others seemed more
shadows as they receded in the background. And then our gaze fell on the city, a city which we had full
reason to believe would be a mass of wreckage. Could it be true that there it stood as we had seen it many
times before? Except for a building partially wrecked here and there, for chimneys down and some coping
stone fallen, the city showed all its spires, steeples, and skyline. We could hardly believe it, and yet there it
was before our eyes. Helena was still holding its own."
THE SECOND QUAKE
Over the weekend of the 19th and 20th, amid torrents of aftershocks, people packed their
belongings and moved to improvised homes. Residents set up tents, moved in with friends or
relatives, or slept in their garages. People continued to leave Helena for more stable ground. Fred
Buck described the days after the quake:
During the interim I packed up the belongings at the house between quakes and hauled the small items
such as pictures, clothes, dishes, groceries, etc., over to Benson's garage while the heavy furniture was put
into storage at Curtin's. It was cold and most any second one could expect a good shake. I worked with the
front and back doors wide open and the runways kept clear so that a hurried exit could be made in case the
plaster got to flying too thickly. Several times I made a flying exit and often I got so weak, tired, and
nervous I would have to go out in the car to rest awhile. The first three or four days I could not eat and
subsisted almost entirely on black coffee.
The people of Helena tried hard to ignore the constant trembles and return to daily life.
During the week after the quake people began repairing buildings, erecting fallen walls, mending
roofs, and rebuilding homes. An article in the Seattle Post-Intelligencer on October 27, 1935, said:
Hardly had the rumblings of the most severe temblor given way to the tremors of more moderate intensity
when Helena residents began searching for ways in which to aid those who were stricken and homeless and
to rebuild fallen structures.
Soon, businesses opened and offices resumed work. Other institutions such as schools and
churches prepared to resume as soon as possible. On October 21, 1935, The Helena Independent
said:
"SO THE PEOPLE MAY KNOW"
Force of Earthquakes Spent
All day Monday the Associated Press and all of its correspondents in whatever city where authorities
could be interviewed with regard to earthquakes, were working for the people of Helena and the readers of
The Independent. The general verdict was that Helena, having suffered its major earthquake, is now the
safest city and the center of the safest area in Montana.
The quakes, however, were not over yet. At 11:37 in the morning, another large tremor hit.
C.R. Anderson wrote:
People, caught unawares, grabbed for support, ran away from walls, jumped to places of safety or clung
where they happened to be. And thus they awaited the end of this shock. But the end did not come, not
with the first second, nor with the next. Instead the trembling increased, the violence became terrific, walls
crashed which had been weakened by so many previous shakes. Eight--ten--
fifteen--eighteen--nineteen--twenty seconds passed, and then the shaking ceased and the rumbling died away.
Once again, people flooded out of buildings, into the streets. Many people were frightened
and surprised; the big quakes were supposed to be over! Perhaps they would never be safe. More
optimistic citizens insisted that the earth had finally settled itself. Rebuilding could continue and
life could go on.
DEATHS
Helena was extremely fortunate in that, through several large quakes and perpetual tremors,
and despite millions of dollars worth of building damage, only four deaths occurred.
Two men died during the quake of the 18th. The first man, Dave Harris, was killed when the
front wall fell out of the Headquarters Building on South Main Street. The man ran out into the
street during the quake and was crushed by the mass of bricks.
The second man killed was Charles Siggelink, a transient who was sleeping in a shelter at the
fairgrounds. During the quake, he dashed through the entrance of the building, and was caught in
the falling debris. Siggelink was transported to St. Peter's hospital for treatment. He died at 7:00
a.m. the next morning.
On October 31st, two men were on top of a stack at the Kessler Brewing Company. Ed S.
O'Brien, 27, and Vincent Kennedy, about 24, were removing bricks from the cracked chimney
when the shock came. The men were thrown off the tower, into the air. Caught in the flow of
bricks and mortar, they were dashed to the ground. Rescuers soon recovered them, but one was
dead when found, and the other died shortly afterwards.
The recent earthquake in Kobe, Japan killed 5,500 people. A quake in China in 1976 killed
800,000 people. Though these quakes were more intense than Helena's quakes, and occurred in
heavily populated areas, they are grim examples of how earthquakes can massacre a city. Despite
falling bricks, walls, and roofs, Helena somehow escaped mass human casualty.
DAMAGE
None of the quakes that occurred in Helena were extremely strong. The most severe quake, on
October 18th, registered 6.2 on the Richter scale. The quake of the 31st registered 6.0 on the
Richter scale. For comparison, the 1995 quake in Kobe, Japan, registered as a 7.2 on the Richter
scale.
However, the Helena quakes, plus the perpetual tremors and aftershocks, caused severe
building damage. Many of the buildings in Helena in 1935 were built from brick and brick veneer
(brick against wooden walls). Unlike "flexible" wooden buildings, these masonry structures could
not withstand the rolling and pitching of the land. Bricks and mortar crumbled in wake of the
tremors.
Building location also affected the amount of damage to a structure. Buildings constructed
over loose rock or gravel retained more damage than buildings built on bedrock. For example, the
Montana State Capitol building, built over solid granite, sustained minimal damage.
The quake on October 18th caused moderate damage to structures, whereas the quake of the
31st caused severe damage. Buildings that had been weakened by the first quake were brought
down by the second quake. Dean S. Carder, of the U.S. Coast and Geodetic Survey, who was in
charge of the seismic observation and recording said in his report:
The earthquake of October 31 caused considerable new damage to buildings apparently untouched by the
former hard tremors, although it is greatly possible that many of these had already been weakened. Earlier
damage was greatly accentuated. Several buildings which had been badly hit by the former tremor were
completely demolished on the thirty-first and many others were rendered uninhabitable.
Damage centered mainly on the east side of Helena, especially in an area called the "Sixth
Ward", on the northeast. Damage was also severe in the area around city hall, on Main Street.
Some buildings on the west side received moderate damage, however the most severe damage was
toward the east.
The following pages describe the damage to buildings caused by the earthquake, and what was
done to reconstruct and restore them. Many of these buildings still survive in Helena today.
After the quake, Helena's two hospitals, St. Peter's hospital and St. Johns hospital, were
required to treat some minor injuries. Hospital staff had to work in the dark for nearly an hour
after the quake, until electricity came back on. This report on the hospitals' activity after the quake
appeared in The Helena Independent on October 19:
The shock had scarcely quieted down after the first severe shaking when 30 nurses and student nurses in
training at St. Peter's arrived at the hospital for duty from the nearby dormitory.
Almost simultaneously, a number of persons living in the vicinity appeared and offered their services
wherever they might be needed. Though devoid of lights, persons living nearby sensing the seriousness of
the situation, rushed in with lanterns, candles, flashlights, and kerosene lanterns.
Emergency apparatus was hastily set up in St. John's operating room to care for the first emergency
cases. Relatives of the injured crowded the hospital halls and nurses and interns rushed about.
Due to the confusion as many hospital patients able to leave their beds fled from the buildings, to be
replaced by the injured.
St. Peter's hospital sustained little damage, and continued to function. St. Johns hospital,
however, was cracked severely, and patients were eventually evacuated from the building.
Patients who were able went home. Those who remained in need of medical attention were
transferred to St. Peter's hospital, or to hospitals in Butte and Deer Lodge.
When St. John's ceased to function, the city was in need of another hospital facility. St.
John's then moved to the Montana Children's Home so that they could continue service. The St.
John's building was later rebuilt in the same location.
Fort Harrison Veteran's Hospital was moderately damaged. Further damaged occurred during
the quake of the 31st. The buildings had to be evacuated, and the veterans were transferred to
Walla Walla, Washington and Roseberg, Oregon.
St. Joseph's Orphanage suffered $50,000 of damage during the quake of the 18th. The school
building and the dormitory building at the orphanage were both damaged severely. The dormitory
walls were cracked, and its main chimney had to be torn down. Three tons of bricks fell from its
rear wall.
The orphans that were living at St. Joseph's spent the night of the 18th in a barn. They later
took shelter in bunk coaches provided by the Northern Pacific Railroad Company. On Sunday, the
orphans were escorted by the Montana Highway Patrol to the Boulder Hot Springs Hotel, owned
by Senator James Murray, who allowed them to live there until the orphanage could be repaired.
The Florence Crittendon Home, where 64 girls and children resided, suffered some minor
damage during the quake of the 18th. During the quake of the 31st, it was damaged severely. The
Home was evacuated after this quake. The institution took up temporary residence in the Episcopal
church, until the original building could be repaired.
Most of Helena's churches suffered minor damage and continued usual services. The churches
that received moderate to severe damage were First Lutheran, St. Paul's Methodist, and St. Helena
Cathedral.
The First Lutheran Church was damaged considerably. The Board of Home Missions assisted
the church in making repairs. During that time, services were held at the Opp and Conrad Chapel,
and in the church parlors.
St. Paul's Methodist Church was the most severely damaged of all the churches. After the
quake of the 18th, the building was considered unsafe. It was further damaged by the quake of
the 31st. Initially, services were held at the Presbyterian church, at 35 North Ewing Street. Later,
Sunday morning services were held at the Rio Theater.
Helena's beautiful Gothic cathedral, on Warren Street, was moderately damaged. The most
extensive damage was on the south tower, however, both towers remained standing. Inside, a
cross made of fine Italian marble fell from the crucifix scene above the main alter. The stone steps
below the cross were also broken. Other damage consisted of a fallen spire and two loosened
pillars.
The damage at the cathedral was minimal enough that City engineer, Oscar Baarson, declared it
safe for the funeral of Governor Frank Cooney, who had died of a sudden heart attack.
The courthouse building, at 228 Broadway, was damaged somewhat during the quake of the
18th. The building suffered two large cracks on the outside, and a chimney on the east side of the
building toppled over. Later, commissioners decided to take down the chimneys because, "they
would be more harmless on the ground than on the roof." Business continued there as usual,
however, throughout the hordes of tremors. Employees at the courthouse worked tenderly,
hovering close to the doorways in case another big tremor hit.
On the 31st, the county courthouse suffered several thousand dollars worth of damage. The
third floor and attic were damaged extensively, as well as the building's clock tower. City
engineer Baarson said that the clock tower would have to be removed, along with some ornamental
stone work. He also said that the third story may have to be removed, but fortunately, it stayed
intact.
The quake of the 18th caused a mass of bricks to fall through the inner ceiling of the jail house.
Twenty-two men and four women prisoners were inside the building during the quake. The
prisoners were kept inside the entrance way, and no one was injured. Jailer Ben Rinda told The
Helena Independent, "All remained orderly, although they wanted to be released. We gave them as
much safety and protection as possible, at the same time keeping them confined to the jail."
On the 31st, the jail was severely damaged. The building was considered unsafe, and the
prisoners were released. All the prisoners were serving sentences for minor crimes.
The Algeria Shrine Temple, presently Helena's Civic Center, was damaged very little in the
quakes. The quake of the 18th caused a 40-foot section of coping to fall from the east wall.
During the quake of the 31st, the upper portion of the west wall fell, leaving a four foot gap
between the roof and the damaged wall. Inside, damage consisted mainly of cracked plaster and
chimneys.
The minaret that adorns the west side of the building rises 174 feet and is built with a steel
skeleton that makes it extremely sturdy. The beautiful, tall tower survived the earthquake
undamaged.
A local myth says that the building once had two minarets, and that one of the twin spires fell
during the quake. However, the delicate minaret that graces the building today is the only one that
has ever existed.
Helena's city hall was so severely damaged that it eventually had to be torn down. Nearly all
the plaster was shaken off, walls were cracked, and partitions fell. The quakes caused the
building's rear wall to lean out more than three inches.
The Helena Police Department was forced to move out of the damaged city hall on October
23rd. For three days, they operated out of a police patrol car, parked in a vacant lot. C.R.
Anderson called this "probably the smallest police station in the United States for the time." They
then moved into a building on East Edwards Street, but the quake of the 31st forced them to
evacuate that building also. After that, Helena's police department resided in the Placer Hotel bus.
The fire department also had to evacuate from city hall. After the quakes, they worked out of
the AA garage.
Only two small fires were reported during the quake. One was in the Helena High School
chemistry lab, and was caused by chemicals that spilled and mixed during the tremors, then caught
fire.
Bricks fell from the back wall of the armory on the 18th, causing the roof to sag over a gaping
hole. Major Sol Pederson, United States property and dispersing officer, was fleeing the building,
and was hit by the falling debris. Major Pederson suffered "severe head lacerations, badly injured
nose and face."
Major E.H. Williams called the national guard out immediately after the quake to patrol streets
and protect the public. A portion of the guards were stationed at the armory to protect the
damaged building's supply of weaponry.
Fortunately, Montana's State Capitol suffered very little damage in the quakes. The building is
constructed of heavy Indiana sandstone, and is built over bedrock. The area around the capitol
suffered severely, but despite damage to its surroundings, the State Capitol survived the quakes
with nothing more than a few plaster cracks.
Businesses that were severely damaged included the Capitol Hotel, Brackman Grocery,
Gordon Mercantile, the Depot drug store, Larson apartments, Curt's grocery, and Montana Meat
Store. Also damaged were the Depot Corner Store, the Northern Pacific land office, the Nash
Finch wholesale grocery company, Christie Transfer, and the H. Earl Clark garage. Plate glass
windows blew out of all the businesses along Helena Avenue. On Boulder Avenue, the National
Biscuit Company was demolished. The Kessler Brewery, was also damaged by the quake of the
18th , and like so many other buildings, damage was accentuated during the quake of the 31st.
Countless other businesses suffered damage during the tremors.
Many homes did not sustain massive damage, only broken dishes, fallen jars, displaced
furniture. Fortunately homeowners survived the quakes with nothing more than some cracked
plaster or broken windows.
However, some homes were severely damaged, especially those located in and around the
"sixth ward". This destruction of homes left over 500 people homeless, facing the chilly fall
weather without shelter or belongings. Fred Buck described the damaged houses in his
neighborhood:
There was not a house in the block that was not either demolished entirely, or so badly wrecked that
they were not liveable. A two-story brick adjoining ours on the West was shaken to the ground and there
were scores of homes within a short radius of us that were demolished. The most severe damaged was
centralized in various localities and we seemed to be about in the center of one of these areas.
During the quakes, tombstones in Helena's cemeteries twisted and toppled. Many of the
tombstones fell or twisted in similar directions. To seismologists, the twisted and turned
tombstones depicted the way the land twisted and turned beneath them. Damage was moderate at
Resurrection Cemetery, four miles north of Helena. Pedestal type tombstones moved in a
counter-clockwise direction. At the Benton Avenue Cemetery, slab stones also twisted in a
counter-clockwise motion. However, pedestal type monuments generally turned clockwise.
Of all the cemeteries, Forestvale suffered the most. Tombstones here twisted and fell, but there
was no pattern or general direction in which the stones moved.
C.R. Anderson described the experience of a man caught in the cemetery during the quake of
the 31st:
A man was encountered in the cemetery who said he had been there when the tremor of the 31st came.
His experiences were not enviable, with gravestones falling all around him, and the many trees shaking as if
'someone had grabbed the trunks and moved them violently back and forth.' It might have easily convinced
any observer that the 'Day of Judgment was at hand.....
Carroll College suffered little damage in the quake. The tremors loosened coping stones and
cracked plaster. Part of two gable walls were also damaged. However, inspectors declared the
campus buildings safe, and classes resumed on November 11th.
Intermountain Union College was not so fortunate. The quake of the 18th knocked out part of
the gymnasium wall, while students were gathered in the gym for a dance, in celebration of their
football victory over the School of Mines.
The quake also knocked plaster and fixtures from the dormitory walls, and damaged furniture.
The college classrooms were damaged so severely, they were unsafe for use. The tremor caused
about $20,000 worth of damage.
The college utilized all available help, including the students, to restore the buildings. Most of
the damage was repaired, and school resumed October 29th. This lasted only two days, then the
destruction came again.
On the 31st, the school suffered so severely, the buildings were uninhabitable. President
Jessie W. Bunch and the other officials on the board, decided to move the college to Great Falls.
The school never returned to Helena.
Helena's public schools suffered more damage from the quakes than many other buildings.
Bryant School and the new Helena High School were demolished, and other schools suffered
minor to moderate damage.
Central School suffered moderate damage during the quake of the 18th. The only damage
consisted of cracks running along classroom walls. The quake on October 31st furthered damage
to the building. More plaster cracked and fell, and the parapet over the east entrance collapsed,
damaging part of the roof.
Kessler School was not damaged severely. Stone coping fell from the east gable during the
quake of the 18th, and some walls were cracked. The quake of the 31st damaged the steps leading
up to the front entrance and fractured the chimney.
Broadwater, Emerson, Jefferson, and Hawthorne schools escaped the tremors with minor
damage. At Hawthorne, plaster cracked and a ceiling light shattered. Plaster also cracked at
Emerson and Broadwater, and the chimney at Broadwater was slightly fractured. The quake of the
31st did not considerably further damage at any of these schools.
Bryant School was not as fortunate. The quake of the 18th ruined the building. Tons of bricks
fell off its walls, and people standing on the street could see the classrooms inside the building.
Everything above the basement level was ruined. The quake of the 31st shattered more walls, and
simply furthered the wreckage.
Students from Bryant attended school in the basement of Central school, until the Bryant
building could be reconstructed.
On September 3, 1935, Helena High students entered their brand-new school for the first time.
The building (now Helena Middle School) cost half a million dollars to construct and was
considered to be one of the most beautiful buildings in the state.
During the quake of October 18th, the school was damaged severely. The walls were cracked,
bricks and mortar fell, and a gaping hole shattered the north wing. C.R. Anderson,
Superintendent of Schools, described the damage:
Examination inside and outside attested to the fact that the building had been subjected to terrific
wrenches and strains in every direction. Going around the building we found less devastation and estimated
the total damage at around 30 per cent. But even with this great monetary loss, and the sorrow of seeing
something so beautiful marred, a prayer of Thanksgiving entered the hearts of all that school had not been
in session when the quake occurred.
Only a few hours before the quake, the school had been occupied by over a thousand students. A
report from the Seattle Post-Intelligencer on October 27, 1935, says "had the quake struck during
school hours, the slaughter would have been terrific and inevitable."
A drama class had been in the auditorium of the school practicing for a play. According to a
school custodian, the teacher "seemed to have a premonition of the coming disaster. She had
dismissed the class a few minutes before debris came crashing down on the auditorium stage."
The October 18th quake weakened the building and its foundation. It could not withstand the
quake of the 31st. The north wing that contained the auditorium was leveled into a pile of rubble.
The rest of the building was a mess of cracked and crumbling walls. By the end of October, at
least 40% of Helena High was demolished. The cost of the damage was $360,000-- 75% of total
building cost.
Because the building was obviously unfit for use, school was dismissed for almost two
months. Near the beginning of December, T.A. Marlow, a director of Great Northern Railroad,
and M.S. Gunn, attorney for the Northern Pacific Railroad, offered railroad coaches to the Board
of Education to be used as classrooms. Each company offered to furnish eight to ten cars apiece,
free of charge. The Board of Education readily accepted. On December 16, 1935, school
resumed.
Due to lack of space, the academic schedule had to be adapted. A college-type schedule was
instituted. Classes were not held every day, but each class was lengthened to a period of one
hundred minutes.
Students often had long periods of time between classes. The weather was cold, so they went
home or sat in their cars while they waited for their next class to start. "This resulted in a lot of
steamed up windows." remembered Betty Sass, who attended the school on wheels. "We used to
go downtown between classes and try on the fancy hats at the department store. The clerk would
cringe when she saw us."
Each coach was heated with a gas stove, but they were still cold. "I remember when a bucket
of water froze in typing class," said Jo Cope, who was a sophomore at Helena High in 1935.
Students were allowed to wear their coats in class and girls were not required to wear dresses.
Still, the winter made the coaches difficult to work in.
The coaches were old-fashioned passenger cars. They had high-backed red plush seats and
windows along the sides. Betty Sass said, "The seat backs were high, so if you crouched down,
the teacher couldn't see you. I imagine there was a lot of laughing and giggling and not very much
studying!"
"The coaches were lined up next to each other, and sometimes kids would hold the answers to
the test against the windows so that the people in the next car could write them down." laughed Jo
Cope.
Regina Thomas, another student, told about when "the girls in home economics would bake
cookies and pass them through the windows to the next car to make points with the guys."
"We had a lot of fun!" Betty Sass admitted.
The students went to school in the coaches for two years. They returned to the repaired
building in the fall of 1938. In a letter to the students, published in the Helena High "Vigilante"
yearbook, Principal W.W. Wahl, whose office resided in a flimsy shed for two years, says "Are
we glad to back in a real high school building? I would say yes, a thousand times, yes."
THE STORIES
The earthquake of '35 was a significant event in the life of Helena and its residents. Even after
the rubble was cleared, the buildings were repaired, and life returned to normal, the stories still live
on. Every person who survived the quake has a tale to tell. When a disaster such as an earthquake
shatters daily life, it is a blatant reminder of how dependent we are on the earth and her stability. It
is this shocking realization of the vulnerability of the human race that causes the event to be
branded into the memories of all who experienced it.
These are the stories of the people who experienced the quake of '35. Beyond the impossibly
intricate tools, tables, and graphs that assess earthquake damage, these stories are the simple, bare
truth of how the quake affected peoples' lives.
Several accounts written by Helenans were published in a magazine called "Letters" on
November 25, 1935. The article, "Footnotes: How an Earthquake Feels", appears here.
"Smashers, Rumblers, Snakers
Sirs:
Bang! A steam locomotive struck the house and awakened me out of a sound sleep. Almost
instantly the locomotive was replaced by a mighty sun-fisher bronco, Paul Bunyan size. I was
riding it. It changed ends in midair, it weaved savagely, and was a mighty mean "hoss". Three
shelves of books hurtled over the bed and on the floor. The smash of crockery mingled with the
clatter of falling canned goods , the grinding, creaking house joists, the thud of chimney bricks
hitting the ground, and a staccato from the kitchen as (learned later) the heavy range danced eight
inches off its base, the boiler stand broke, the stovepipe came down and things were a mess
generally.....
I heard my wife call and got up. She says she called loudly before but that I was too scared to hear
her.
.....No use to clean up the mess until we felt it wouldn't be worse so we piled into the car to
survey Helena. Every main highway leading from the city was filled with fleeing cars. Passing
the Shrine Temple, I observed a car with passengers, parked directly beneath the tall tower (which
still stands). Glad they felt safer there than at home.
The tremors kept coming. We were parked on a rear street.....Following one shock, the door of a
small brick house opened and out came a strapping young Negro, followed by an old mammy.
"I'se goin' away from here, sudden,' he told the woman. 'You can't escape from the Lawd,
sonny, you can't escape from Him; He's sho to follow you wherever you go.' Across the street
an irate husband and a frightened wife were in a violent argument. He was cleaning up the debris
in the house but felt it was woman's work, but his wife wouldn't enter, and his efforts to make her
do it forcibly failed.
A naked man, dazed, ambled down the street carrying an alarm clock. In contrast, there was a
miner who returned to his boarding house after the quake, not aware that there had been one. The
building was pretty badly wrecked and everyone else had fled. The miner, too tired to be
observant, parked his car in front, went upstairs and climbed into bed. Two hours later, his
landlady, who had been riding the night out, passed by and saw his car. She and her friends
decided to see if the miner was in the house. They found him in bed, a grayish pallor on his
countenance. First he was thought dead, but he was breathing too hard for that, so they yelled and
pulled at him until he opened his eyes. They told him what happened, that the house might tumble
down any moment, and he should get out at once. "To hell with the quakes," he answered. "If
the Republicans were in , we wouldn't have them." And over he turned in bed to sleep until
morning.....
There was a guest at the Placer hotel who heard the other guests frenziedly getting out. He rushed
to leave his own room, but couldn't open the door. He yelled, but the scurry of feet down the hall
did not stop. He grew frantic because couldn't open the door. Finally, when the hotel was
cleared, this guest suddenly recollected something.....Then he turned the key that unlocked the
door, opened it and walked out.....
Mr. and Mrs. Alfred Brass were in St. John's hospital visiting a woman who had given birth
to a baby a few days before. After the quake the woman wanted to get out. Mr. Brass carried her
down to his car. When he opened the door he found the back seat stacked with brick. Not a
window was broken, but the car top had been neatly cut away by a falling chimney.
Some people fled from Helena following the first major shock of October 12. The city was
nervous but not markedly so. Confidence was being restored when the 20-second major shock
struck at 10:50 a.m. on October 31. Then Helena got jittery. It had lost all confidence in experts.
Rumors became facts. The quake was not tectonic but volcanic. A blue sulphurous haze was
around the mountain tops. The rumbles were not created by a vacuum of air, but were the stirrings
of a mighty volcano in the Prickly Pear Valley at the foot of Helena that would destroy the city.
Fortune tellers and almanacs had predicted these quakes and more to come. Strangely, one never
talked to a person who had seen the almanac or visited the fortune teller. It was always a friend
who had done this.....
Every temblor has a movement all its own. Sometimes it is a grand smash with no warning.
Sometimes it is a deep rumble. One waits to feel the tremor. It does not always come. Sometimes
it is a rumble and a smash, or maybe a smash , a rumble and then a quivering agitation. One
young matron has fittingly described them as "snakers". In the last day or two the rumbles have
almost entirely disappeared. While there have been some of five and six seconds' duration, to
layman they appear to be diminishing in force. Some last night were of the slow, creeping,
crawling kind, insinuating themselves into your consciousness. Then the bed quivered, as if it
were resting on a mountain of flesh.
The earthquake epidemic was particularly hard on the nervous systems of children from two to
eight. I don't believe this was always a reflex of their parents' attitude. Children of many became
hysterical and could not be calmed until they were taken elsewhere.
Some dogs were affected just as much as the children. Cows lowed and moved uneasily.
Horses charged madlong across the fields. Chickens (at least ours) were unaffected, but the
turkeys began gobbling and flopping around on the roosts.....
Helena has lost all faith in the newsreels. Most of the pictures taken at Helena have been
staged, from the rescue of a woman by the State fire marshal, to taking out the injured on stretchers
from the state armory. Buildings wrecked years ago (not by the earthquakes), but not demolished,
have furnished splendid atmosphere for the movie cameras.
-Chas. D. Greenfield, Montana Life Insurance Co.; Helena, Mont.
Thrilling
Sirs:
.....Helena is rapidly becoming earthquake unconscious .....On October 18 the big 40-second
shake came about 9:47 p.m. I was in the Rio Theatre. A low rumbling sound could be heard such
as of an express train on a high trestle, which blended into a noise much stronger but of the same
character as that of the noise used by carnivals in the snake tent. The floor vibrated as the stern of
the Berengaria at full speed ahead. The lights went out, people arose but had no difficulty in
walking. It was over. No one screamed. People walked out quietly groping their way in the
dark.....
One slightly tipsy fellow in a "soft drink parlor" had just announced that he could whip any
man in the house. The shock came and everyone rushed to the street. Oblivious to the quake he
turned to where the bartender had been standing and said: "See! They're all scared of me!.....
A friend of mine immediately after the shock said to his wife that he could not breathe for dust,
asked that she open a window. She entered the bathroom to open a window, found the rear wall
of the house gone, went to an adjoining room and to her surprise the entire front wall had
disappeared. I asked one man if he heard the noise when the side of his two-story brick house fell.
He said not--that while the quake was on he rushed to the street, noticed the crumbled wall of a
nearby store building, casually looked around and to his consternation saw the side of his own
house was gone.....
A Red Cross worker, visiting a lady in a house which had been seriously damaged, felt
impelled to walk to the street, the lady following her. As they left the house the second jolt came
and the building collapsed.....
The county Court House being rendered unsafe by the continual tremors, the Clerk of Court
now carries the Court seal in his pocket, does business where we find him.....
While these earthquakes are a thrilling experience, news gatherers not satisfied to report real
facts, delight in exaggerating reports. One newsreel photographer asked refugees in a relief camp
to remove some of their clothing and shiver so that the suffering would be more realistic. They
refused. But a day or two after the second quake city firemen did rescue a lady from the second
story window of an abandoned building, smashing the glass, carrying her down the ladder, etc.,
for the Hearst-Metrotone Newsreel cameraman. Photographers were seen snapping an abandoned
school which has looked like the ruins of Kenilworth for at least five years that I know of.....
-Arthur P. Acher, Attorney at Law, Helena, Mont.
Brag
Sirs:
We were so contented in this little city up near the Continental Divide! No cyclones, floods, or
dust storms. Some of us bragged a bit.
First came a little rumble and a shake, just enough to make barber shop conversation and to
remind us that all was not will. A more severe jolt, this on Oct. 12, made the town quake
conscious. Some said they were "jittery."
.....On October 18 a big shock made history. It changed the face of the city, killed two,
paralyzed business, closed schools, made tenting popular, placed us in the national headlines,
sprouted a new bunch of heros.
Chief of these heros was the apartment house tenant who, in the darkness and excitement of
those terrible moments, collided with his with, carried her to safety and then found it was the lady
from across the hall he had rescued. His own soul mate later crawled from the wreckage and
explanations were in order.
Another, a bartender drawing a stein, fled down the street in his white apron, to return long
after and shut off the tap.
A lucky boy was the one who could not get open the screen door. While he struggled the
porch collapsed.
Then more tremors and after eleven days another major shock with more death, destruction,
and destitution. Mercury dropped to below zero.
One might say that Helena people, as a whole, are cheerful but nervous. Even as I write this a
sudden tremor went through the building. What is yet to come? We jump and wonder. If we
boast now it will be about this wonderful, invigorating Montana climate.....
-Thomas P. Regan, D.D.S. Helena, Mont.
"Cutitout! Gotohell!"
Sirs:
.....Slight rumblings and moderate tremors continued daily setting more and more on the verge of
exhaustion from fright and helplessness in the face of nature's manifestation of power and might.
Many Helenans retired at night partially clothed under their nightwear, with flashlights and car
keys within easy reach, their coats and footwear across the foot of their beds. Subsequently many
residents left town each and every night, repaired to nearby resorts which had not felt the temblors
and returned to business in the morning. Others awakened by the minor shocks dressed, packed
families in cars, drove to the airport seeking solace in the "All's Well" flash of its green beacon
every ten seconds plus the safety of wide open spaces.....
On October 31, the third violent shock of unusual duration was experienced in the face of a
rapidly falling barometer and thermometer. Weakened buildings tumbled completely, others,
having withstood previous quakes were cracked to the extent of making further occupancy
extremely hazardous. Additional residents left town. A matronly bridge club of eight, reduced to a
foursome by the previous quakes became no quorum at all after this shock.....
Helena matrons soon became experienced seismologists, able to report the direction of
movement of the latest earthquake by the number and location of open drawers throughout their
homes.....A very talkative parrot became unusually quiet except at the start of a new tremor when a
rapidly shrill "Cutitout! Cutitout!" continued for several seconds unless the quake ceased within
that time, or tiring, he uttered a guttural "Gotohell!" as they failed to cease at his prior command.
Our friendly little dog, loving and well loved by the children, would rise from her bed, make the
rounds of each bed in the house, listen for signs of life and slowly return to her own troubled sleep
only when assured of her masters and friends safety.....
Hotels located in the business district became practically vacant. A report of the hasty exit of at
least one guest after a slight shock may give the an idea of the uppermost desire of everyone to get
going. This gentleman, without bag ore baggage, clothed only in pajamas rushed from the lobby
to a nearby bus, clambered aboard, with only a gasping entreaty to the driver, "I don't know where
you are going but let's get there quick."
Many people, after the reported experience of the sheriff who arrived home after the third
severe quake to find his bathtub filled with brick and stone, were reluctant to even venture near a
bathtub, much less draw a tub, their worry: the fitness of their garb should a quake occur while
engaged in their ablutions.....
Today,.....the city is hesitantly and cautiously turning to the repair and rebuilding of its future
being. But relatively large numbers of home and property owners in Helena are elderly retired
agriculturists, cattlemen or their relics. Many of these, ordinarily comfortably situated
financially.....having suffered depression since 1928.....after this catastrophe made decisions
which will have far reaching effects upon the future rebuilding of Helena. Losing homes,
apprehensive of further increased taxation in a town reputedly at the peak of allowable
indebtedness, well along in years, they moved out of the city back to ranches and many out of the
State to spend remaining years with more virile offspring. Since the last ounce of gold has been
taken out of Last Chance Gulch (Main Street, Helena) many years ago, there remains nothing to
attract the zestful active initiative of youth in rebuilding the town. Helena remains just and only the
capital of Montana.
-G.R. FitzGerald, Airways Extension Supt.; Miles City, Mont.
That's That
Sirs:
.....We were sitting in the living room of our home listening to a radio program.....when the entire
house started to rock, shake, and quiver as though it were being pulled in all directions at the same
time. The large pictures on the walls seemed literally to fly out into the room and turn over.....We
started to run for the front door and just as we reached the porch all of the lights in town went
out--nothing but darkness and the tense feeling of some terrible catastrophe. Then out of the dark
came the shrill sounds of hundreds of cars hurrying, hurrying through the night.
The first thought that entered our minds was that the young son of the family was attending a
movie some six blocks from home. Hurrying to the theater through the dark streets we found
men, women and children running out of all the entrances guided only by the lights of the cars that
had rushed to that point, everyone frantic with fear, yet making no outcry. We learned afterward
that the most nerve-racking part of the experience of those in the theater was seeing the plaster from
the ceiling falling in front of the screen....
Where buildings were of brick veneer, the bricks shelled off like corn off the cob. In the case
of solid bricks or stone buildings, the sides or front or back would be entirely removed and the
furniture in the rooms would be exposed to view. One strange thing was a car of liquor that had
been spotted at a warehouse. The warehouse collapsed, the roof falling on the car and almost
cutting it in two. Only six cases of whiskey were damaged.
.....Some of the finest institutions of the community were badly wrecked, this being particularly
true of the Catholic Orphanage on the edge of town, housing 125 little children, who with the nuns
were compelled to seek shelter in the dairy barn until the railroad officials placed cars on the tracks
at their disposal.....While the children were in the cars one of the railroad officials said, "Well,
where would you like to go--will it be New York or California?" A tiny girl replied, "I don't want
to travel. I want to stay here and have earthquakes."
.....The residents of the town feel the same way....When a quake comes along, we just smile
and say "Well, that's that." -
Edith G. Briscoe, Acting Secretary, Montana Liquor Control Board, Helena, Mont.
*****
The following are stories and anecdotes from the chapter "Pathos and Humor", from C.R.
Anderson's Montana Earthquakes:
"Better Stay In"
After the quake of the 12th, one family tried to rush out of their house through the back
door, but found it to be stuck tight, and no amount of pulling could open it. Investigation
later showed them that bricks from the chimney had fallen right in front of that door. They
were in the same house when the quake of the 18th came along. This time they tried the
front door, and imagine their surprise when they found this one stuck. They were duly
thankful when they found the second floor balcony had shaken loose and fallen directly
into the path they would have taken.
"Crack the Whip"
At one home the husband and wife were in the living room and dining room
respectively, when the crash came. Knowing the added safety of being under door lintels
when possible, they both made a rush for the wide opening between the two rooms. They
reached that position, but went beyond as each was catapulted into the room vacated by the
other. This happened twice before they could manage to stay upright.
"Just in Time"
Caught on upper Main street at the time of the temblor of the 18th, a party of three were
in their car in front of a soft drink parlor. One man was perched with a foot on the running
board and was handing glasses of malted milk to his two friends in the car. When the
shake came and continued, it seemed to the man on the side of the car that the buildings
were certainly coming down on them. He stood for a second entranced, and then shaking
himself into action, shouted to the driver to get going. The driver, confused and unable to
coordinate his muscles and will, fumbled with the starter, but finally the car roared and the
suddenly meshed gears shot the car down the street. Just a second later, a wall of brick
came down in the exact spot where they had been parked. A more shaken but thankful trio
could not be imagined when they finally reached open spaces.
"Cats"
Many reports came concerning the strange antics of the feline species before and during
the tremors. Some reported that these animals would throw a kind of fit just prior to the
shaking, while others said they observed them jumping wildly about just after it happened.
One cat was seen to throw a fit and then fall over dead. In one home a man had just cut off
a chunk of meat and placed it in a pan by the kitchen range. Just as the hungry creature
was getting ready to sink his teeth into the choice morsel, the quake came, and in a flash the
cat jumped out of the nearest window and has not been seen since. So much for nine lives.
"Fair Exchange"
Two automobiles were approaching each other on a narrow road some 17 miles from
Helena. On one side was the steep bank to the Missouri river, and on the other side was a
cliff. When they were just a short distance apart the temblor came and a huge pile of rock
and dirt came tumbling down onto the road between them. As there was no possible way
of getting past, the men did the sensible thing and exchanged keys and cars.
"Just a Coincidence?"
Two small girls were sleeping together in an upstairs room. The temblor came, shook
loose part of the roof and a timber came hurtling down through the bed just between the
two girls, who were left unhurt. This is somewhat similar to the case of the mother who
went up to get her baby from its crib and found the latter half-filled with brick. She finally
uncovered the baby--unhurt.
"London Calling"
The London Press called Chief Roger Smith of the Helena police force a few days after
the quake. Chief Smith went to the telephone and gave a very conservative report of the
earthquake and the damage done. Clippings from the London newspaper were later sent to
the police chief, and among other reports were the following:
'TOWN RUINED--WOMEN AND CHILDREN FLEE.
How earthquake shock after shock hit a town and shook it to pieces, how its 6,000
women and children fled in the dark along roads which suddenly gaped in chasms
and were showered with debris.
'Helena, Montana, a mining town 3,955 feet high in the mountains,
has suffered 600 shocks since Saturday. Yesterday all able-bodied men among the
20,000 inhabitants were still fighting to save life and property.....The terrified
people believed that the whole mighty range of the Rockies might be breaking up.
'TOWN UNRECOGNIZABLE. Helena was still in the grip of the
terror. From a town which claims to be the richest of its size in America has been
reduced to a heap of ruins.'
Chief Smith opined that his words certainly fained embroidery as they went of their
5,000 mile trip and was thankful that he had had witnesses to his end of the conversation.
"Where Were You?"
When earthquakes come they give no warning, and wherever one is at the time is not
one of its considerations. Many Helena residents found this out to their extreme
embarrassment when they were caught in the bath.
"Lena"
From Bozeman comes the interesting information that the city of Helena is now called
Lena. This was due, they say, not so much to the leaning tendency, but because the
quakes have shaken the Hell out of it.
*****
This is an account by Joanne Maynard. She experienced the earthquake as a little girl, and this
is her story:
The Earthquakes
I was born in Helena in 1931, so I was four years old at the time of the earthquakes. I think
that my memories of them are interesting because children remember things in a different way from
grownups.
The first big earthquake was at night. I was asleep upstairs in a crib and my parents and some
of their friends were playing bridge downstairs. I woke up and thought that a dragon was coming
up through the heat register that was in the corner of my room, to let the heat from downstairs
come up. I thought that the dragon pushed my crib around the room. I still have a mental picture of
that dragon. I didn't know what an earthquake was - had never even heard of one. But I knew
what a dragon was.
As I've heard the story told, the men of the party ran outside. The women went upstairs to get
me. My crib had rolled - not clear around the room - but across the doorway, so that my rescuers
had a hard time getting into the room.
The next thing I remember is being wrapped in a blanket and handed to a lady who was sitting
in the back seat of a car. The dome light was on, and I was surprised at a light inside of a car. I
realize now that, because we had a little roadster with a canvas top, I wouldn't have seen a dome
light before. This car must have belonged to the bridge players.
The next thing I remember was being at my grandparents' home, which was about three blocks
from our house. The electricity was off. I had to go to the bathroom. I suppose my mother went
with me, carrying a candle, but, of course, it would still be dark in the bathroom. My grandmother
had cleaned the toilet earlier, and the toilet-scrubbing brush had been stuck under the seat to drain.
I sat on it, and I think that scared me more than the dragon or anything else that happened. I still
remember that sensation.
I remember that we had cocoa (Grammy must have had a gas stove) with a marshmallow on
top. Then I was put to bed. The bedroom had a slanting ceiling, and I thought it was falling down.
But I remember this as merely a curious fact, not something to be afraid of.
By the end of the month, we were back home. Maybe we went back home the next day - I
don't know. On the day of the earthquake, I was sitting on the kitchen floor, "cooking" something
on a toy stove and my mother was standing at the real stove, where some split pea soup and some
graham muffins (ever after designated as the "earthquake lunch") were cooking. I felt something
and said to my mom, "There's going to be an earthquake." She tried to calm my fears and be
reassuring, but the earthquake did come shortly after that. I suppose that children can tell, the way
they say that animals can.
My mother got panicky and wanted to run outside. I was the calm one by that time, and
reminded her that we had been told not to go outside, but to stand under a doorway, which I
suppose we did. But it wasn't long before we hurried down the hill to my grandparents' house
again. My uncle and aunt were there, and when my mother remembered that she'd left the soup
and muffins cooking, my uncle went up and got them, and we all shared them for lunch.
We lived in an elderly duplex made of brick. The wall at the back leaned out, so that you could
look out between the back and side walls - or so I remember it. Iron rods were put through the
house and tightened with braces on either end to draw the walls back together. As I remember it, a
rod went right through the room, and we could sit on it. My grandfather (not the one we stayed
with, but the other one) was a blacksmith, and his shop made many - or maybe all - of the iron
rods that were put through Helena's buildings after the earthquakes. You can see the braces on the
walls of many of the older buildings. The duplex where we lived is still there, and looks very nice
even now.
There were a lot of small shakings. We had a side board with plates on it and they kept falling
off. So my mother got paper plates and painted them with water colors in various designs, coated
them with shellac, and used them instead of the real plates. I still have a couple of them. At the
time, I thought she was the most wonderful artist in the world, to be able to do that.
My mother was expecting a baby in June, or maybe July of 1936. She visited the doctor during
this earthquake time, and before he realized that she was pregnant, he began telling her about all of
his women patients who were losing their babies because of the earthquakes. That didn't do much
to set her mind at ease. But she did fine. The interesting thing is that, because she was startled by a
small earthquake on June 13, 1936 - which was my fifth birthday - my sister was born on that day
too.
At some point, after the big earthquakes, my mother and I went out to Townsend to stay with
the parents of a friend of hers. My mother was born in Townsend and lived there until she was in
high school. We went there so I could get some rest, because the doctor said I was having a
"nervous breakdown."
I can remember being driven around town and seeing some of the damage. I remember a house
with the front wall gone, so that it looked to me like a doll house. And I remember being with my
grandparents outside of town somewhere - maybe by the Scratchgravel Hills - and seeing big
cracks in the ground.
I've always felt that the earthquakes weren't as bad as they've been made out to be. But
recently I realized that my parents probably down-played what was happening, so that I wouldn't
be afraid. So I never knew what was really going on.
*****
From Mrs. Jack Schultz' Genealogy Book
"Events to Remember"
The 'earthquake', at 9:45, October 18, 1935, I was in old hotel we lived in at Winston,
I was undressed and ready for bed, as it happened, I was alone in the house. I was sitting
on a low stool near our old potbellied coal and wood stove. I turned to a book case to find
something to read, the light flickered (this was the first year we had electric lights, it was
drop cord type from ceiling with light bulb). I turned to look at light, it was swinging
slightly--9:47--light went out, building began to shake, noise all around me, plaster and
items falling in rooms upstairs, glass falling in room I was in as three windows smashed. I
didn't know what it was, decided the world must be coming to an end, put my head in my
hands and 'didn't even try to stop it,' I told people later (when I could talk!). After what
seemed like a lifetime, shaking stopped, dead silence, total dark. Off in the distance I could
hear my name being called, couldn't answer, shock.....I guess. Finally realized Mom was
out on porch calling me, so squeaked out "yes". Stumbled in bare feet to door and outside.
My mother, Dad, and several others were anxious that I was okay. They were next door at
the Winston bar. They knew what it was, realized I was alone, tried to get out the door but
were not able to do so, because it jammed and moved during the quake. You wouldn't
believe a few seconds could turn you into a quivering mass like jelly. I thought I was
tough, tomboy type, not afraid of much, but I learned from that experience. Combine
dark, being alone, no knowledge of what was happening.....you will be able to compete
with any earthquake with the shakes that follow. The earth shook all night, so did I. To
make matters worse, all telephone lines were down, no communication, it was not too great
in those days at best. Neans was in Helena, another lady in Winston had a daughter here.
Nothing would do except get to Helena to see if we could find out if they were all right.
Fellow there named Harry Smith had a car to bring Mom, Dad, Mrs. Sass, and me to
Helena. All the way in , Harry Smith kept saying 'everybody in Helena will be
dead'.....we should have taken him out of the car, have Dad drive him over several times
and proceed on our way (last place I wanted to be was Helena), he really made everybody
feel great. As we got close to Helena, we first thought the lights were on. It was car
lights, so many were moving it seemed town lights were on. We found our Neans and
other lady's daughter were okay. I don't remember seeing them, but we found out
something. I remember sitting in the car up on Broadway, you could feel a constant tremor
under the car, me too. Never did I stop shaking that night. Returned to Winston. Tried to
go to bed, nobody slept. Banging at the door for Dad to go out to check railroad bridges
and track before the trains came through. He left. Bed is shaking (me), Mother is in bed
with me. Too much, Mother was a natural coward, scared of the dark, scared of being
alone. Mild quake felt, I shake more, we got up, went down to depot to be where there
were others. By this time, it was getting daylight. This is the basic of what happened, all
the things and thoughts could go on and on.
October 31st there was another of about the same intensity. I don't even remember it
(now), it was a Thursday around noon. Suppose I was with other people, also, it wasn't
dark! Two people were killed in first quake, two people in second quake. Most places
don't have quakes as Helena did. They had mild ones before the first big one 6.5, they had
almost continuous mild ones until October 31st, then another big one 6.5 Usually there is a
big one, then quakes of decreasing violence. Leave it to Helena to be original. No wonder
the Indians considered this area to be "taboo". Amen."
*****
Schoolgirl
Yes, I remember quakes of '35. My younger sister and I were taken to the Deaconess
School in '33. We were in bed asleep, when the quake hit. Our housemother came and
told everyone to get in line and we would go outside. The school was five miles from
Helena. The whole 5th floor was shook off. But, everyone in the school was outside and
one housemother was the last one and a brick came down, hitting her on the head. We
were all put into the garage, and people were coming to help. Men were upstairs throwing
mattresses and bedding out of the window. The next day, our housemother took us for a
week and I remember playing in the leaves. The next day my Dad came to get us and I
wasn't very happy to leave--we were having such a good time. When we returned to
school it was a building on the end of Helena--I graduated out of the 8th grade there."
--Mrs. Edith Gray
*****
Football Game
Well, to tell the truth, I never personally experienced it, felt it that is. I don't remember
the exact date, but it had to be late September or early October. I do know, it happened on
a Friday evening--(around 9/9:30 p.m.) I was a member of the Fort Benton (Long Horns)
football team. The only school in our conference, at that time, that had a 'lighted football
field' as Conrad. I don't remember exactly what time the game started, probably 8 p.m. I
forgot the exact score, but I know we won--(21/6 or 20/7) something like that. I remember
running to their gym (whoopin' and hollerin') we had WON! As we entered, we noticed
they were setting up a band on a stage at one end of the hall. There was going to be a
school dance, after the game. Well, there was a lot of noise; guys yelling, all the 'showers'
going full blast; we were in the basement. At first our Coach Zile said, 'No,' we couldn't
stay for the dance. Finally, after we all protested, he said we could stay for 30 minutes,
since we won the game! Well, we went up the steps to main floor-- strange, nobody was
in the gym--noticed the bass drum lying on its side--one or two horns on the stage floor.
Went outside, a few people standing around, talking about an 'earthquake'--the dance had
been canceled (I think Coach Zile was smiling). Well, he treated the whole team to a
milk-shake at "The Barrel" as we passed through Great Falls on the way home to Benton.
That night/morning in bed (2-3 a.m.), I felt my bed shake for a few seconds--definitely an
'aftershock'....."
--V.R. Elliott
*****
Movie
A friend and I were at the movie at Marlow theater. We were up in the balcony. When
it started to shake, the lights went out and bits of plaster started falling. We all made it out
okay. There was no panic or screaming. We made it up where our car was parked,
through the mess at home. There was a lot of mess, etc. One man was killed near where
our car was parked. At that time I was working downtown at a store called Strain
Brothers. But no one wanted to come to work except two managers and I and another girl.
The four of us kept it open for days. Also, my parents had a dairy farm not far from town.
We didn't miss a day. They brought in the milk to our customers on time every day. What
we called the 'sixth ward' was hit the hardest. It was a poor section of town.
--Dani Englund
*****
St. Vincent's Academy
In 1935 I was a student at St. Vincent's Academy--that was the Catholic School that
was condemned after the quake. I can still remember the scary feeling we all had at the
time. We were in a dormitory on the 2nd floor. I remember looking out the window and
everything was a bright blue color. You can imagine the panic of 50 or so girls. Sister
said, "Now we will stay in our beds and say the rosary. Everyone settle down and lay
quietly." When we were finally allowed to get out of bed, we put on our robes, and were
led downstairs. A lot of the stairs were damaged so we had to slide down the banister.
What fun! We spent the night on the lawn with many blankets. As the building was
condemned (I'm not sure how many days passed), I was sent back to my family in
Anaconda. I still get that panicky feeling when a train goes by or I fell another quake.
--Betty Sager
*****
Ghost
At the age of 14, my brother, 12, and I went along with our mother. We had just left
an old fashioned Catholic wake and went across the street to the neighbors. At the wake
there must have been 40 people. As the coffin started rocking, the house cleared out. I
think a lot of them thought some spirit had them. My brother was so scared he said it was
still shaking where he was standing.
--Emma R. Smith
*****
Butte High
I remember being in Rialto Theater in Butte the evening of that quake. It must have
been Friday because Butte High was to play Helena High the next day. I remember the
chandelier in the theater swinging in at least a six foot arc in the theater ceiling. I'll bet the
shocks were much more intense in Helena, but they were quite severe in Butte too. I was
on the Butte High football team. We got on the bus the next morning to go to Helena to
play football, but received word in Boulder that the game was canceled, so we did not
proceed and came back home.
--T.L. Cragwick
*****
The Noise
I was with two friends (Carl Hill and Tom Regan) in front of my dad's drug store in
the Union Bank Building, on the corner of Main and Edwards. We heard the quake and
saw it coming as low waves up the street. I told my friends to get into the doorway right
under the building wall.
Most memorable was the noise; aside from the quake's rumble, there was the sharp
"whack" reports as cornice stones hit the sidewalks. Also, the squeaking and squealing as
though a hundred piglets were being tortured as the plate glass windows were pinched in
their shifting metal mullions and frames. I could write for hours about the quakes, but I
will just say that the whacks (very loud) and the screeching and squealing are the things I
couldn't possibly forget."
--Bill Reynolds
*****
This is a selection from the memoirs of Perry Brackett. He was a young boy when the quakes hit.
Helena Earthquakes
My first experience with earthquakes came on October 18, 1935, in the evening. I'm
not sure of the exact time but I would guess somewhere around 8:00 p.m. and I can
remember it as well as if it had been last night. My Mother and Dad had taken my sister
and I with them to visit some family friends who lived about six blocks northwest of where
we lived. We were all sitting in the living room and the first thing I remember is the
chandelier began to move back and forth and then as the quake picked up intensity it
assumed more of a circular motion. I was sitting in a chair next to my Dad who was sitting
near the door. The next thing I remember is my Dad pulling me over into his lap head first
and then he bent over me. I was 12 years old and my sister who was six years older, about
this time announced that she was getting out of there and headed for the door, as she
approached the door my Dad grabbed a hold of her and held her keeping her from running
outside. I later learned that running outside is not the best thing to do in an earthquake.
Then the electricity went off. When the shaking died down and everybody gained their
composure, we all ventured outside. There did not seem to be much visible damage to the
house we were in. Then the folks and the couple we were visiting, along with another
couple who were there from an area near the Northern Pacific depot which we called the
sixth ward, decided to visit the other homes. We all went up to our house and fortunately
found no damage. The only things we noticed were a violin setting on edge on top of the
piano had tilted backwards and was leaning against the wall. Also, a baseball bat that was
standing on end in the corner had fallen over. We considered ourselves very fortunate.
We then all traveled down to the home in the sixth ward and we soon realized that we were
coming into the area that received the most damage. When we reached the home of the
other couple their home was intact on the outside, but it was a different story inside. This
lady had a pantry full of canned goods in glass jars and they were all over the floor and of
course the jars were broken.
The electricity was off all over town and all you could see was car headlights. I
remember my Dad saying it was as though someone had kicked into an ant hill. Cars were
everywhere and anywhere. Some of them just wanted to get out of town. Some of the
buildings looked as though someone had taken a knife and sliced away an outside wall.
You could see the different floor levels of the house and the bedroom furniture in the
rooms. I remember seeing a home where the bathtub was exposed, and I remember
thinking "what if someone had been in taking a bath at that time".
There had just been a new high school completed in Helena and the first freshman class
had started there in the fall. My sister had just graduated from the old high school in June
of that year. I was in the sixth grade at Central School and the boys in our class had spent
the afternoon at the new high school for an introduction to manual training, as they called it
in those days, now of course it is better known as shop or industrial arts, anyway, to get
back to the story--the auditorium of the high school, which was directly over the shop, had
completely collapsed. This made me realize how fortunate that the earthquake had come in
the evening and not during the day.
That night none of us went to bed, the folks got out the blankets and my sister and I
slept on the floor in the kitchen. There were aftershocks all night long, some more severe
than others, and our dog Dandy would check on us every time one would come.
People in Helena were really frightened and many left to never return. I remember one
family who recently built a small log cabin and they wanted to leave Helena and wanted my
Dad to buy their house. My Dad tried to talk them out of going but they were insistent so
he did buy the house and my folks used it as rental property. The little cabin is still there
today, and is still in our family.....
The quake brought an early end to the school and schools did not start again until after
Jan. 1, 1936. This meant that I had a lot of time and not much to do, so I began helping
my Dad. He had a transfer and fire wood business and the earthquakes increased his
transfer business. People whose homes were damaged had to find a new place to live.
Then there were those who no longer wanted to live in Helena and take a chance of another
earthquake. Even though it was hard work moving furniture and cutting wood, I enjoyed
it. It gave an opportunity to spend a lot of time with my Dad and of course Mother liked it
because she knew where I was. My Dad had a 1 1/2 ton Chevy truck and during this time
he taught me how to drive. He also hauled coal as well as wood because these were the
main sources of fuel in those days.
I remember once during this time when we went to the coal yard for a load of coal; we
always had to pull on the scale to weigh the empty truck and again on the way out to
determine the weight of coal we had loaded. When we arrived at the yard, I was driving
and my Dad left me in the truck and went into the scale house and left me behind the
steering wheel, which I could hardly see over. After the truck was weighed, my Dad told
me to pull into the yard and back up to the proper coal bin. Mr. Guffey, who owned the
coal yard said, "Your not going to let him drive it in there are you?" My Dad's response
was "He can do it as well as I can." That made me feel good and as I reflect back I realize
that those words gave me a lot of confidence. Mr. Guffey in later years when I would see
him, would often mention about the truck without the driver because when we pulled up he
couldn't see me.
Later while hand loading some large pieces of coal, I was trying to throw one in the
truck and I accidently hit my Dad in the head and almost knocked him out.
After the first of the year we all went back to school and the kids who were in high
school had the unique experience of going to school in railroad cars. Since the high school
had been so severely damaged, the School District and the City made arrangements with the
Northern Pacific Railroad to park several passenger cars on a siding to be used for
classrooms. This seemed to work out okay, except winter months in Helena can be pretty
cold and students and teachers alike kept their heavy clothes on all day.
Bryant school in the sixth ward was also damaged and the kids from Bryant were
moved into the basement of Central School.
--Perry Brackett
****
LaVere "Sis" Southwick experienced the quake as a freshman in high school. The following is
her account of the earthquake:
Year 1935. My first year of high school. I lived with my Aunt and Uncle at 709 9th
Ave. My room was on the third floor of the apartment house.
I started school at the old high school on Warren and Lawrence Street. The new high
school on Rodney Street was just being built. We moved into the new school September
3rd, 1935 and enjoyed the spacious rooms and long hallways. It was a real treat from the
old building.
Beginning on October 3rd we felt small earth tremors, but did not think much about
them as it was not unusual to feel small tremors that year.
Two weeks later we began to take notice. It was a more scary thing to feel so many
little tremors, and on the 12th at midnight a more severe tremor turned into a shake, dishes
rattled, pictures hung crooked, and the earth seemed to rumble. During the following
week, small vibrations were making us more aware that this was not quite normal.
On October 18th, in mid-evening, a sudden sharp quake hit with a rumble like unto an
explosion. It lasted a few minutes and the rumble faded away. We thought now it is done
with whatever and will be over.
So my cousin and I went to the Marlow Theater to see a Jack Benny movie. We liked
to sit way high in the theater so we could look down on the movie. At 9:30 the seat seemed
to be moving, a low rumble was quite obvious even as the movie was so interesting. It got
worse and worse and the air seemed to fill up with smoke or dust. Looking down we
could see the large chandelier swinging in a big arc, and the chains that held it were rattling.
Then the lights went out. Panic hit and people were screaming and trying to get down to
the ramp. We got on the ramp and it seemed to be swaying from side to side. People were
pushing, falling down, and panic was at its utmost. One lady fell and was screaming for
someone to help her. It seemed the shaking would never stop and dust was so thick we
could taste it.
Everyone was pushing to the bottom floor where the doors were. It was so dark
outside all the lights were out in downtown Helena.
As my cousin and I finally got out we realized a man was holding us each by the hand.
We did not know him but we were mighty thankful that we were out of that building.
We started to walk down Main street (in the middle) as we were afraid the buildings
would fall down on us. As we made our way up Sixth Avenue, many people were going
home, or just getting away from the high buildings.
People were all out of the houses on the yards, loading in cars that were available. And
few cars were around at that time.
The streets were rolling and it was hard to stand up. Chimneys were falling and bricks
were falling off houses. Cement walks were cracked and made it hard to walk without
falling.
People were afraid to get back in the homes to get supplies needed to stay out of home
for fear of collapsing. People with trucks made beds for elderly and children in the back of
the trucks. Cardboard was a much needed item to make shelter for the people. The
National Guard put up tents out in the valley and at Fort Harrison for those who could not
get back in the homes, or were afraid to.
My parents, Edith and Owen Warren, lived at Beaver Creek (Nelson). My Dad had the
Montana Power Station at that time, and they heard the news of the quake in Helena, so
they came to town to take us home.
Out there the power lines were swaying and big rocks rolled down the gulch behind our
house. My Dad said before the quake hit the horses were nervous and wanted out of the
corral. The chickens were flying around in the chicken house, and it was so very quiet
when the rumbling stopped. No birds or animals around.
For three weeks we stayed out at the house before going back to Helena to school.
Many relations came out to Beaver Creek to get away from the city.
Many people took what they could in their cars, never to return. Homes were left
empty. It was so cold that the cold seemed to be coming from the cracks in the earth,
which were many. Deep crevasses were seen in the Helena valley.
By December 16th the railroad had moved in railroad coaches on tracks to be used as
classrooms for the high school. Some heat was made in them but they were cold. Typing
class was a disaster. Typewriters slid off desks and were ruined, so class was closed.
Teachers braved the inconvenience and cold to teach, but the bitter cold made it hard to sit
for very long.
It was a bad year but we came out winners, maybe not in learning at school but being
thankful we still had homes and loved ones unhurt from all the happenings of the Big 1935
Earthquake.
AFTER SHOCKS
The earth beneath Helena continued to shake for six months. During October, tremors were
intense and frequent. They became milder as the winter progressed into spring. On April 26,
1936, a 24-hour period passed without a single tremor. This was the first day in nearly seven
months that Helena did not have an earthquake. Over the entire six months, 1,310 noticeable
tremors occurred.
The people of Helena became accustomed to the frequent shakes and shudders, and were able
to continue their daily lives. A small, and somewhat exaggerated article appeared in the Boston
Post:
Real Courage
Fire may level a city, droughts make a desert land of a countryside, and floods sweep away the building
of a lifetime. But such disasters pass and the residents bravely build again. Yet more disastrous to
property and contentment are the endless earth shocks suffered by the residents of Helena, Mont. Since Oct.
18 that city has felt 1,004 shocks. It must be a frightful experience to be shaken night and day, with death
imminent at any moment. There is no chance to plan anew while the shocks continue. Living there must
be a nightmare. One can get used to just about anything except the solid earth shaking constantly. Only
the pioneering spirit of the early founders that is still retained by the present generation keeps the city from
becoming a wilderness. If Congressional Medals of Honor were given to groups for outstanding courage
this community would deserve one.
RELIEF AND RECONSTRUCTION
Buildings in Helena were uninhabitable, and over 500 people were left homeless after the
quakes. After the quake of the 31st, a cold spell hit, and temperatures dropped to below zero.
People needed shelter, food, and clothing.
The Red Cross, FERA (Federal Emergency Relief Agency), The Salvation Army, The National
Guard, local churches and clubs, and many other volunteers rushed to aid Helena.
Policemen and National Guardsmen were on duty immediately after the quake of the 18th.
Along with 25 volunteers, Helena's police force roped off streets and patrolled the city. 40
National Guardsmen assisted the patrol on the night of the 19th. For many nights afterwards,
guardsmen patrolled the city to prevent looting and to ease panic.
Looting, however, did not appear to be a problem in Helena. Only one case of looting was
reported--a purse was stolen from a police officer's house, when he was called out on emergency
duty.
The Red Cross also went to work immediately. The organization helped supply food, shelter,
household goods, medical supplies, and hospital attention for those people in need. Workers also
helped clear debris and repair homes. The Red Cross spent a total of $94,056.63 on supplies and
reconstruction for the city of Helena.
The Salvation Army set up a refugee camp in a warehouse at the Green Meadow farm.
Donations supplied cots, mattresses, blankets, clothing and heating stoves for the camp. A
first-aid center and an emergency kitchen were set up. Nurses, doctors, ministers, and many other
citizens donated time, money and supplies. The refugee camp operated until December 8th, when
it was not needed anymore.
The Great Northern and Northern Pacific Railroads set up heated railroad cars for people to
sleep in. An average of 90 people slept in the Great Northern cars for 17 nights, with 165 being
the greatest amount at one time. Many people also slept in the Northern Pacific cars.
On the afternoon of the 19th, a refugee camp was also set up at Camp Cooney, west of Helena
by the National Guard. 100 heated tents from the armory were set up, and 400 people spent the
night of the 19th there.
On the 19th, City Engineer Oscar Baarson toured the city to examine the damage. He found
many buildings to be unsafe, and condemned those that were uninhabitable. State Fire Marshall
Arthur C. Parsons, with City Engineer Baarson and other city officials declared a ban on all public
gatherings until buildings could be inspected and repaired. Churches, theaters, saloons, and all
other gathering places were temporarily closed.
At noon on the 25th of October, this ban was lifted. Buildings that had been properly
inspected were granted certificates of occupancy by city officials. It was though that the big
quakes were over, and reconstruction could continue.
But on the 31st, the next big earthquake came, and the ban was reinstated. Once again, all
public gatherings were forbidden. The ban was not lifted until all buildings were inspected and
granted occupancy.
Congressman Joseph P. Monaghan was the first public official to come to Helena to inspect
damage and assist the city. Monaghan notified President F.D. Roosevelt of the damage to Helena.
On Saturday afternoon, he also wired Relief Administrator Harry Hopkins. The telegraph read:
Visited Helena today: damage done by earthquake inconceivable. More serious damage threatens unless
relief workers from other parts of the state can be ordered here immediately to assist in removing shaky
construction and bolstering up infirm walls and chimneys, also direct relief necessary for helpless and
homeless people. Please act quickly and advise.
Congressman Monaghan contacted Secretary of War, George P. Dern also. The telegraph to
Dern follows:
Many hundreds homeless tonight as result of terrific earthquake, Helena, Mont. last night stop.
Visited city today find people in streets in desperate condition stop. Please arrange for camp stoves bedding
and tents and army emergency relief equipment as needed stop. Act promptly tonight and advise.
Monaghan sent telegrams to the federal housing administrator and the federal home loan
administrator as well.
Other officials to bring aid to Helena included W.M. Ruffcorn, state relief administrator; Tom
McCabe, county relief administrator; Riley Mapes, state director of transient relief; Miles
Romney, director of the state emergency council; F.H. Marvin. director of emergency relief for
the FERA; Barclay Craighead, state director of the Federal Housing Administration; U.S.
Representative Roy Ayres, and U.S. Senator Burton K. Wheeler.
Senator James E. Murray also assisted in obtaining aid for the city, as well as donating his
Boulder Hot Springs Hotel for the use of 140 homeless orphans from St. Joseph's Orphanage.
Governor Frank Cooney located state funds for Helena, and also broadcast several pleas over
the radio for relief and aid.
Soon, federal and state funds were pouring into Helena. President Roosevelt saw to it
personally that Helena receive a large amount of federal funding. This funding helped immensely
with reconstruction and aid for the homeless.
*****
By 1936, Helena was almost back to normal. Tremors continued throughout the winter, but
Helena survived through them all. Many buildings had to be torn down because of the quake,
such as the National Biscuit Company, and Bryant School, but despite these, Helena's
reconstruction continued. Some residents of Helena became so frightened by the quakes, they left
the area forever. Those who stayed rebuilt Helena into the "Queen City" we know today.
.....
Newspaper Article: "Talk about a big upset..." published in The Independent Record, Helena,
Montana, Sunday, October 29, 1995. (Edition with focus on 60th
Anniversary of 1935 earthquakes)
Author: Harriet Meloy, a student at Intermountain Union College in Helena,
Montana, at the time of the earthquake 60 years ago
Location at time of earthquake: Gymnasium of Intermountain Union College, attending a
dance following a big football game
________
TALK ABOUT A BIG UPSET... A first-hand account
by Harriet Meloy, Special to the IR
October 18, 1935:
Al Lundborg, Lew Chittim, Freddy Ranf and Roland ("Fuzzy") Ortmayer played football for
Intermountain Union College that day; "Fuzzy" carried the ball for the fourth-period touchdown
that won the game, 6-0, against Montana School of Mines. They played in Helena, on the field
east of the IUC gymnasium on the site now occupied by the Capital Hill Mall.
Intermountain's win over the Butte Orediggers was the first recorded in a long series of
contests between the two colleges. Tension ran high during the game. At one time fists flew,
bringing the Helena police to the field. Intermountain's hard-won victory was the first of two
historic events on that 1935 October day.
After the stunning victory, about 200 students, faculty, and friends, gathered for a dance in the
gymnasium. Even the most reluctant dancers, energized by the day's excitement, soon encircled
the floor.
Rumbles Felt
At 9:50 p.m., six injured players sitting near the west wall of the building heard a deep rumble.
A few moments later, the dancers also felt a second rumble, which marked the onset of the area's
most violent earthquake.
At 9:52, before the lights went out, the brick walls of the new gymnasium swayed in and out,
like sides of a large empty packing box in a windstorm. Then all the lights went dark. The
stunned crowd stood silent in the inky blackness. Then voices murmuring and feet shuffling, the
crowd moved quickly and quietly out-of-doors. Apprehension gripped the crowd; just as the light
died they glimpsed a hole in the wall on the west side of the gym. Above the low talking and
moving feet, a voice assured worried friends that most of the west wall bricks had fallen outside,
that everyone was safe.
Black Night
I vividly recall the warm air and the black night that enveloped us as we filed out the south door
of the gym. I remember gazing down Butte Avenue to Montana Avenue where my two-story
home was, and worrying about my family. My father was away; and my mother was home alone
with two sisters and a brother. Had the old brick house withstood the quake? Fortunately, my
date, A.J. Kempenar, offered to walk home with me to see how my family fared.
Our home at 815 Montana appeared intact. Later, however, we discovered that the heavy,
stone-encased windows in the dining room were so shaken out of their casings that daylight
appeared through the cracks.
Telephone lines were still operating and the Lymans, Mabel and Ranney, invited us over to
spend the night in tents on their lawn on Peosta Street. By the light of flickering candles my
mother and my siblings packed suitcases to move to the Lymans where tents were being erected. It
seemed safer for us to remain outdoors.
AFTER DRIVING my family across town, my date and I returned to campus where a group of
IUC men had just returned from celebrating the day's victory by lighting the "I" on Mount
Ascension, (a tradition observed after every winning game.) The celebrants described seeing a
flash across the sky, at about 10 p.m., as the city lights disappeared, rocks rolled down the hill and
trees swayed. The men told of scrambling down the steep path in the night's blackness, and
running to the campus to find, with relief, that classmates were safe.
Near midnight, several students carried mattresses from Mills Hall, to sit on while they
watched the parade of automobiles exiting Helena (moving slowly -- bumper to bumper.)
Paradoxically, others were heading into the city to view the destruction.
EAGER TO LEARN more about the results of the quake, several students suggested walking
toward Main Street to observe the damage. My date and I joined them. We didn't feel the
continuous quakes when walking. Lights glowed in houses along Broadway enroute to the city
center.
At the end of Broadway, National Guardsmen informed pedestrians that the entire length of
Main Street was barricaded. Militia patrolled the streets to warn unauthorized personnel away from
tall buildings. They told us of the death of a man who was caught by a shower of brick as he ran
from a building on South Main.
Leaving the battle-like scene of Last Chance Gulch, we strolled back to the college campus.
We stopped for a few minutes to sit on the low stone wall surrounding the Court House. The earth
still shook. How strange the sensation of sitting on solid granite yet feeling the earth shake under
us. No one considered the danger of the tall Court House tower that might tumble at any moment.
WHILE WE CLASSMATES talked about the events of the evening, we speculated that the
earthquake might change the couse of our lives. What would be the fate of 200 college students if
IUC were unable to finance the restoration of damaged buildings and continue?
Intermountain College did leave Helena soon after the quakes. It moved to Great Falls, and
eventually became a part of Rocky Mountain College in Billings. Students dispersed to various
other higher education institutions. Most Helenans have forgotten the little college east of the city.
But those attending Intermountain on that October night long ago, will never forget the school, the
football game, and the earthquakes of 1935.
Just ask Al, Lew, Freddy -- or me!
Memoirs: Fred Buck , State Water Conservation Board, Helena, Montana
written December 17, 1935
Addendum: Mary Buck Jelinek, his daughter
written April 2, 1989
Obtained from: Montana Historical Society files, Helena, Montana
Location at time of earthquake: second floor of office building, Helena, Montana
__________
EXPERIENCES OF THE FRED BUCK FAMILY
IN THE HELENA EARTHQUAKES OF 1935
Since June, 1925, a period of ten years, Helena, Montana, had not experienced an earthquake
of note, and those that had been felt were mere tremors compared with the major ones of 1935.
The first jolt came early in the evening of Thursday, October 3rd, 1935. We, the Fred Buck
family, were sitting in the front room when it was noticed that pictures moved slightly and there
was a gentle tingling of dishes and bric-a-brac. All was quiet again until about one o'clock the
morning of Saturday, October 12th, at which time the first severe shock occurred. This lasted
twelve seconds and shook the house until the walls seemed to be weaving in all directions. Its
severity aroused us out of a sound sleep soon enough to witness the last half of the shake up.
There was no doubt what had happened; nobody stopped to ask, "Was that an earthquake?" In a
few minutes, the populace of the whole town was in the streets. No one could sleep through it.
Many people spent the rest of the night in their cars.
We hurried downstairs in night clothes, turned on the lights, and took positions on the
davenport near the front door. The front door was left ajar, too, in case a hurried exit was
necessary. Every few minutes from then on for the next two hours there were lesser tremors.
Finally, the early morning chill drove us to venture back upstairs for some more clothes, and a
while later, we retired to the bedrooms to lie down until daylight. We were nervous and excited.
Every new tremor added new excitement, and the waiting for the next shock, which might be
harder still, whetted our nerves to a keen edge. Juanita was so sure that that was only the
forerunner of what was to come that she could hardly force herself to stay in the house at all, and
she was right, for had it not been for her uncanny premonition, some of the family might have
been killed or seriously hurt in the terrific shock that wrecked our home on the night of Friday,
October 18th.
The six days that intervened between the 12th and 18th were trying on the nerves, to say the
least. Shocks kept following shocks, some severe and others mild, but none of very long
duration. It is the ones of long duration that do the damage to life and property. The city suffered
some minor damage in the way of fallen chimneys, broken plaster, and cracked walls, but no one
was hurt.
I asked the state engineer the next morning if he was scared, to which he answered, "No, I
wasn't scared, I was terrified." This is the best description of one's feelings that I have heard and
just fits the way everyone felt. A veteran of the World War remarked, "I'll take my chances in a
shell hole anytime in preference to this." If such remarks were initiated by this quake, which, by
comparison with the violence of later ones, was hardly a cocktail to a dinner, we wonder what
expressions, if any, could be expelled from the same lips later in the shakes that followed.
Juanita had become so nervous that when I returned home next evening she pointed to a
bedroll, suitcases and clothes that she had collected and piled on the floor, and gave me orders that
they were to be packed into the car that very night for emergency's sake. She was so sure that we
would have to take refuge in the car before the thing was over. It struck me funny. I smiled and
tried to kid her out of it, but no, she was in dead earnest, so in the car they went.
The next day, Tip Napton, one of the boys working for me who had been through the major
quake in Los Angeles in 1932, came into the office to ask how we survived. He said that he had
walked downtown that evening and thought to himself that if it were California he would be sure
that we were in for an earthquake, as the temperature and feel of the air were just right. He then
said to me confidentially, "You know what I would do if I were you? I would pack a bedroll and
some clothes in the car. I'm not kidding you a bit. I know from experience what happened in
California, and you better take my tip and be prepared." When I told Juanita this it bolstered up
her convictions, and I came in for a good chiding to the tune of "I told you so." The luggage
stayed in the car until noon of the 18th, when I unpacked and piled it up in the dining room, much
against my wife's wishes. (She claims it was not so much against her wishes as it was the
embarrassment of having the neighbors see what she had in the car.)
The fore part of the week preceding the 18th, the shocks began to boom up in frequency and
intensity, which terminated with three heavy ones on Tuesday, then settled to a dead calm on
Wednesday evening after a few scattering quivers. All day Thursday and Friday, scarcely a tremor
of note was felt. It might seem that people were beginning to like the rocking from the anxiety
caused by this stillness, but not so. Everyone interpreted it as a warning. The earth coming to rest
in such a sudden, deathly calm after a series of crescendo shocks proved to be a bad omen, as
people suspected.
When I came home for supper on Friday evening, Juanita was very nervous over the stillness
and felt confident that something was in store. She spoke about it several times before I returned
to do some night work at the office. Shortly after leaving home, there was one very severe shock
(or "jolt" describes it better) with not a single after-tremor. This magnified the nervous anticipation
of the coming event, no one knew what, nor how severe, nor what the toll of life might be, but,
nevertheless, the event seemed inevitable.
At the fatal moment, nine-fifty p.m., to be exact, six engineers were in my office consulting
over the design of a storage dam when the crash came. We jumped out of our chairs but could not
stand up only by holding onto something solid. The noise alone of grinding brick and groaning
timbers, the rattling windows, and roar of the quake itself, were enough to terrify one, to say
nothing of being jostled about like a lone marble in a tomato can. About that time, the plaster
began showering from the walls and ceiling, and in the midst of it all the lights went out. There we
were, trying to stay on our feet while being swatted with falling plaster in the ghastly darkness. It
was an experience I never want to go through again. Every second I expected to be shot out of the
window to the pavement below, or have the walls crash around me. This terrible shaking kept up
severely and constantly for a period of 32 seconds -- it seemed like 32 minutes. As soon as the
worst was over, we struck matches to pick our way through the dark halls, over the plaster, and
down the stairs to the street. The earth and building were still trembling. The choking dust that
filled the air was as thick as a heavy fog. Old Mother Earth reminded me of a dog full of fleas
shaking himself to get rid of the dirt.
As I unlocked the car to hurry home, two women came running up so hysterical they didn't
know what they were doing. One threw her arms around me, imploring, "For God's sake, take
me home quick. My child is in the house alone." Not until we got out of the business district did I
begin to realize the seriousness of it. The pavements were strewn with brick and lumber; people
were running as though they were insane; women were screaming as though in death; the streets
were alive with cars; and the weird yellow cast of headlights piercing the thick blanket of dust was
uncanny.
When near the neighborhood of where these two women lived, I asked them several times to
tell me when to stop, but they were so excited they didn't pay any attention to me. Finally, one of
them threw her arms around my neck (they were both in the backseat of a two-door sedan so it was
necessary to fold back the front seat in order to get out) and said, "Stop, Stop, Stop!" Before I
could stop, both of them were out of the car and clear across the street. I never will know how
they got out of that car. The house was almost demolished; the front porch was crumpled in a heap
and the brick wall had fallen out of the bedroom where the child lay sleeping. As I got there, a
man came out of the ruins carrying the baby in her night clothes. She was a six-year-old girl, so
frightened that she couldn't cry. How she escaped death was a miracle.
I hurried on eight blocks more to my family and, upon arriving, found them seated on the
bedding, suitcases, etc., in the parking space across the street from the house, where there were no
buildings. I will never attempt to describe their fright, nervousness, fear, and anxiety for my
safety. They knew I must have been killed or I would have been home before now. By this time,
there was not a soul in Helena, it is safe to say, that was inside any building. They were out in the
streets, in cars, and clustered in groups on vacant lots. Fortunately there was no snow, and the
night was not very cold.
To complete the story, I'll take up the movements of the family from dinnertime until I met
them again about ten-twenty. The baby had gone to sleep, and Juanita was so uneasy that instead
of taking her upstairs to bed as usual, she had parked her on the davenport near the front door and
had dragged out the bedroll, suitcases, and clothes and piled them up at the front door. Juanita
played the piano for awhile and then went to the phone to call me to come home. She grabbed the
baby, ran across the porch, down several steps to the sidewalk and was clear across the street
before the lights went out. She said the porch pillars danced a shimmy and seemed to bounce up
and down as if they were made of rubber. Several milk bottles came rolling off the porch after she
had gotten across the street so we know she lost no time. It was her alertness and anxiety that
saved herself and baby from what might have been a serious accident. Mother Evans was not far
behind, and they both got out before wreckage began to show itself in the house.
The ground continued to shake and tremble all night, almost constantly. The records show that
there were 174 shocks during the night.
After packing the car, we drove around to find some of our friends who did not have cars, but
in all the confusion we couldn't find anyone we were looking for. About two o'clock in the
morning, we came back to the house to see what damage was done, and turn off the gas. It was a
spooky feeling to open the door and peek in, one that made cold shivers run down your back.
About the time one would get up courage enough to venture in a few feet, another pop would bring
down more plaster and you would bolt for the door.
The house was a mess; a huge chunk of plaster buried the piano where Juanita was sitting only
a few seconds before. The ceiling was unusually high and the plaster was the old, thick type that
had enough weight in falling so far that she would have been badly hurt if struck with it. The
kitchen window was blown out completely and landed on the table right where the baby ate her
lunch before going to sleep only a short while before. In the front room, a big bookcase full of
books was thrown down in the middle of the floor just after Juanita had crossed in its path to grab
the baby; the radio was hurled clear across the room; stand lamps were upset and the floor was
strewn with bric-a-brac, pictures, vases, etc. The refrigerator, which weighs five or six hundred
pounds, was moved out about eighteen inches from the wall. In the hallway upstairs, a heavy
bookcase full of books was jiggled out into the center of the hall until it met a trunk that had moved
out from the opposite wall. In the kitchen, broken dishes were piled up in a heap where they had
slid out of the cupboard; bottles, fruit jars, syrup, beans, flour, etc., covered the floor; then over
the top of this conglomeration, the fallen chimney had spread a thick layer of black soot.
A peculiar thing about the wreckage in the house was that everything was thrown from the east
toward the west. Things hung on the west wall, or setting tight against it, were not disturbed, but
everything against the east wall was dislodged. Against the west wall in the bathroom hung a frail
medicine cabinet full of bottles, etc. Not a single article in it was upset, but on the opposite side,
which would be the east wall of the kitchen, the dishes and groceries were thrown out of the
cupboard onto the floor. The basement seemed to survive the best of all the house as the only
thing disturbed there were two cans of fruit, which had upset and rolled off the shelf. In a flimsy
board shed in the backyard, I had piled up a lot of empty tin cans that had been used for flower
pots, and not a single one was moved. Such are the freaks of earthquakes.
The solid brick house in which we lived (531 Fifth Ave.) was split on all four sides and one
wall bulged out of plumb about eight or ten inches and pulled loose from the inside partition. The
bricks in the back of the house were almost all either shattered apart or split. Archways over all the
doors and windows were broken until the entire loads of brick above were resting on the wooden
casings. Although the building had been very substantially built, it suffered structural damage that
did not show on the surface. We noticed this in particular when moving the furniture out, which
would make the floors and walls shake and creak. Two boards on the front room floor bulged up
the full length of the room.
There was not a house in the block that was not either demolished entirely, or so badly
wrecked that they were not liveable. A two-story brick adjoining ours on the west was shaken to
the ground, and there were scores of homes with a short radius of us that were demolished. The
most severe damage was centralized in various localities, and we seemed to be about in the center
of one of these areas.
One of my engineers, Norman Benson, found us at the house about three in the morning after
hunting for us all night. Nothing would do but to go over to his house until we could get located
again. His home was a little four-room frame, which was far too small for his wife, three kiddies,
my wife, Mary Clarabelle, Mother Evans, he and I, but his generosity was so thoroughly backed
up with his insistence that we camped with them for the following two weeks, or until the next
major quake came on the 31st.
During the interim I packed up the belongings at the house between quakes and hauled the
small items such as pictures, clothes, dishes, groceries, etc., over to Benson's garage while the
heavy furniture was put into storage at Curtin's. It was a spooky job. The days were short so that
the daylight hours were brief; the house was cold and most any second one could expect a good
shake. I worked with the front and back doors wide open and the runways kept clear so that a
hurried exit could be made in case the plaster got to flying too thickly. Several times I made a
flying exit, and often I got so weak, tired, and nervous I would have to go out in the car to rest
awhile. The first three or four days I could not eat and subsisted almost entirely on black coffee.
You never saw such a pile of junk as there was in Benson's garage after it had been assembled
on the cement floor. The weather turned cold during the next week while Juanita and I were trying
to sort stuff out and arrange it in some kind of order to pack. Between this job, and trying to keep
warm, and running out doors every little while to escape another quake, Juanita and I became
much better acquainted with each other's dispositions than ever before. Then, too, living in such
small quarters with four small, noisy children, and not being able to sleep nights or eat right, just
aggravated the situation.
People were living in tents pitched on vacant lots all over town. Many people slept in their cars
from two to three weeks and many left Helena to take up abodes in neighboring towns. Garages
were made liveable while other people moved into homes with friends who were more fortunate.
As an example of the congestion, I know of one place where 19 persons were sleeping in a one-car
garage. Houses were scarce in Helena before the disaster, and when some 460 homes were
completely destroyed or badly damaged, as the census showed, you can imagine the congested
conditions.
During all this time we were house hunting every spare minute, but you couldn't find a vacant
house, tourist camp, garage or chicken coop -- one fellow did offer me a tent. At Fort Harrison,
some hundred or more townspeople were housed in army tents pitched hurriedly for the occasion;
the Great Northern Railway Company brought in several Pullmans to accommodate the homeless.
Had it not turned cold right afterward with a light snowfall, conditions would not have been so
tough, but, at that, nobody really suffered.
None of us could find a single thing we owned or wanted. I had a razor and toothbrush in my
overcoat pocket and an extra pair of socks in the car, which were about the only personal
belongings I could locate for the two months that we were homeless.
The thirteen days intervening between the 18th and the 31st were days filled with earthquakes:
some 24-hour periods would record as many as 25, many of which were light jars, and again,
many were good shake-ups. On the 30th, things began to quiet down again, and then
people took on new alarm, for peace and quiet were bad signs. At 11:30 the next morning, the
violent shock struck with all the force and duration of the major one of the 18th. It was not quite
so terrifying, though, as it happened during daylight hours, but the damage was perhaps more
severe. It shook continuously for 27 seconds. As I glanced out of the window, the west brick
wall fell from St. Charles College building.
My office was a madhouse if you ever saw one: more plaster fell; women and girls were
hysterical; and nobody could get out of the building until it was over. As the walls vibrated in and
out, I expected every second to land in the street amid a pile of brick and lumber. They bulged and
cracked until you could look out upon the sky around the ceiling, but fortunately the walls did not
fall or some of us might have been hurt. As it was, the building was wrecked to the danger point
and every office and business in it ordered to vacate immediately. The building is being
reconstructed, and while repairing the upper story, it was discovered that the floor joists had pulled
away from the walls until only 3/4 of an inch remained that was resting on the brick. Just a trifle
more bulging of the walls and our floor would have crashed to the ground. In the meantime, the
office was moved to a road house known as the Nite Owl, which is three miles outside the city.
After the major part of the shock was over, the ground kept quivering almost constantly for
about an hour. The records show that there were over 100 shocks during the afternoon. By this
time there were no human nerves left in the city. Streams of cars radiated out over the highways in
all directions, for the majority of those who had cars left town.
As the day was cold, I had parked the car in a public garage about half a block from the office.
I ran to get it but the attendants were all out in the street, and it took a lot of persuasion to get one
of them to go back with me long enough to get it out. My only escape was through the alley,
which was built up solid on both sides with dangerous brick buildings, and adjoining was a tall
stack that had cracked some ten feet below its top and was expected to fall any moment. I was
desperate, though, to get home to the family as soon as possible, so I took a chance and safely ran
the gauntlet up the alley, past the chimney, and over fallen bricks from the wall of our office
building.
The family was pretty excited, but no damage was done to the little frame house where they
were. When I arrived, all of them were tramping in the snow out in the yard and wrapped in
blankets to keep warm. As soon as we could get things together, we pulled out that afternoon for
Great Falls and rented an apartment. I returned to salvage what was left of our wreckage and later
brought the family back to Helena to camp with the Tarrants, who were old friends of Mother
Evans in the Black Hills many years ago. Not until the 6th day of December were we able to get a
house in Helena and move into a new home, after sixty days of homeless wandering.
The shock of the 31st just about finished the house where we were living the night of the 18th
when it was cracked to pieces. The back door was torn off its hinges and slapped down on the
floor; the big kitchen range was upset and the connections torn loose from the water tank. The
water main was broken in the front yard. Had we been in the house at the time and could not have
dodged the remaining plaster that fell, there is no telling what the results might have been with a
shock severe enough to play such havoc.
Even yet, old Mother Earth keeps up her shimmies. On Thanksgiving morning there was
another that lasted twelve seconds and shook things up good, bringing down more brick and
plaster. Had the other catastrophes not been so fresh in mind, we would have been inclined to
class this one as a major shock. Up to midnight, December 17th, the time this is being written, we
have had a total of 1203 quakes since October 18th and are still having them. There have been
eleven shocks within the last twenty-four hours, some of which are classed by the Weather Bureau
as "moderate intensity."
It is almost safe to say that there is hardly a building in Helena that is not damaged to some
extent. A recapitulation of the damage now being compiled by the city engineer shows that out of a
total of 3500 buildings inspected in the city, 1789 were damaged from 2 % to 100 %, and the
survey is not yet completed. Besides the 460 homes ruined, some of the larger buildings
condemned are: the county courthouse, St. Johns Hospital, a new half-million dollar high school,
Bryant School, the cracker factory, Montana Deaconess Home, St. Joseph Orphanage, county
poor farm, city hall, county jail, Intermountain Union College, numerous stores and office
buildings. Some of those badly damaged but which can be repaired, are: Montana Children's
Home, Florence Crittendon Home, Shrine Temple, the cathedral, Denver Block, Fort Harrison,
Northern Pacific Depot, Great Northern Depot, the Methodist church, Hawthorne School, Central
School, the old high school, many stores, office buildings, and apartments.
Intermountain Union College was moved by truck to Great Falls, and the Veteran's Hospital,
which was housed at Fort Harrison, was moved by special train to Walla Walla, Washington.
Whether these institutions will eventually rebuild their buildings and return to Helena is still
problematical. High school is being conducted in a train of railway cars and the grade schools will
not be reopened until the first of the year. Temporary quarters will have to be provided until the
school buildings can be repaired, and it is planned to send half of the children in the forenoon and
the other half in the afternoon in order to be able to accommodate them all.
During the first shock of the 18th, two men were killed and three more were taken on the 31st.
Several have died since as a result of shocks. The hospitals were filled with injured, and when St.
Johns Hospital went down on the 31st, its patients were hurried to Butte. When one drives around
the city to observe the wreckage, they can't help but wonder why more people were not killed.
The fact that people were so nervous, alert, and held themselves ready to run is probably the
reason.
In several places, small cracks opened up in the earth after the severe shocks. In one locality
down in the valley, a large crevice belched up water, which brought up volcanic ash sufficient to
build up small cones six to twelve inches high. The ash was undoubtedly brought up from an
artesian flow, which was intercepted by the crack.
After the shocks of both the 18th and 31st, the main part of the business district was roped off
to prevent auto travel. It was not necessary to prevent pedestrians from entering the restricted
district, for people were afraid to venture among the tall buildings, and even yet, a good many
were reluctant about going downtown to shop. Business houses were all closed for two or three
days and the city was practically under martial law, although such had not been officially declared.
City police, the county sheriff's office, the state highway patrol, and the state militia all joined
hands to protect the populace and prevent looting.
We learned after experiencing a series of quakes that if the earth kept quivering after a severe
shock that there was not much danger of anything more serious happening, but if the earth settled
down to composure, it was a warning to look out for something more. In other words, continual
shakes quieted our minds, but silence generated uneasiness. With every quake, there is a distinct
rumbling, which sounds like a heavy truck. During recent days, as the disturbance is subsiding,
we can often hear the rumble very distinctly but do not feel the jar. It makes you wonder if old
Mother Earth does not need a laxative.
The quakes, from their behavior, classify themselves into three distinct types: first, the severe
ones, which shook continuously for several seconds and did the damage, the ones that jostled you
in all directions at the same time; second, the quivering kind, which were short in duration, and
from their behavior, were locally called, "The Stutters"; and third, "The Jolts," which would hit
one vicious crack, like some heavy object striking the building with great force. Sometimes this
latter kind would seem to be a side crack, and again, they would strike vertically as though the
force came from the basement. Some of them would fairly make your neck pop.
With every catastrophe there are always amusing sidelights. The evening of the 18th, a
salesman driving into the city, who had not felt the shock, couldn't imagine why so many cars
were on the highway leaving Helena. He saw a woman standing on the walk and asked, "What on
earth is the trouble; have all the people in Helena gone crazy?", to which she indignantly replied,
"What's the matter with you, young man, are you trying to be funny?" A fe |